Eighteen months, one idea
In April 2025 Nigel Farage said Britain was “massively over-diagnosing those with mental illness problems” and “creating a class of victims”. The charities queued up to call it misinformation. I wrote at the time that this was no neutral policy point. It was an old anti-psychiatry worldview with a new microphone.
Today, 17 November 2026, the government published Alan Milburn’s review of young people and work, From a Welfare State to a Working State. It never uses Farage’s words. It doesn’t need to.
For under-25s it abolishes the Work Capability Assessment and the Universal Credit health top-up. It replaces PIP with a new allowance for disability costs that are “significant, well established and ongoing”. The vocabulary has changed. The direction of travel hasn’t.
This is how an idea gets a suit and a position in a labour government cabinet.
“They Call It Over-diagnosis”: Nigel Farage, John Mappin, and the Return of the Mad Psychiatrist Trope
When Farage calls children with SEND “over-diagnosed,” he’s not just dog-whistling to sceptics of “woke culture.” He’s echoing a deeper, older, and more dangerous tradition.
Where the trope comes from
The idea that psychiatry invents illness didn’t start with Farage. Its modern home is the Church of Scientology.
L. Ron Hubbard treated psychiatry as the enemy. In 1969 the church co-founded the Citizens Commission on Human Rights (CCHR) with the psychiatrist Thomas Szasz. CCHR is widely described as a Scientology front group whose job is to push the church’s anti-psychiatry agenda (Wikipedia). For decades it has gone after Prozac and ADHD medication. It still calls for investigations into the “drugging” of children for “so-called ADHD” (CCHR press release).
That’s the original script. The diagnoses are fake, the treatment is the harm, and the people diagnosed are being turned into victims.
Mappin: the bridge
John Mappin is where that script meets British right-wing politics. He’s an heir to the Mappin & Webb jewellery family and owns the Camelot Castle hotel at Tintagel. He spent six years studying Scientology (Wikipedia). In 2019 the Daily Mail reported he was a “practising Scientologist”. The Guardian has described him as a QAnon believer who has posted praise of Vladimir Putin (Guardian, 2021). One family who stayed at the castle said two Scientology DVDs were later sent to their eight-year-old daughter (Wikipedia).
Mappin and Farage
2019. Mappin was involved in creating Turning Point UK. He and Farage both attended a Turning Point UK fundraiser at Camelot Castle, at £180 a head (Guardian; Wikipedia).
2020–21. Mappin, founding chairman of the carbon-offsetting firm DGB, introduced Farage to it. Farage took a monthly retainer to promote it (Guardian). openDemocracy and The Times later described the pair as briefly business partners in a Scientology-linked company (openDemocracy).
GB News. Mappin appeared on Farage’s GB News show to talk about refusing to house asylum seekers at Camelot Castle (Wikipedia).
2026. An openDemocracy and Times investigation, which I supplied data to, found Mappin had repeatedly promoted the “anti-woke” Awoke Coin to his followers. Farage now denies any link to him (openDemocracy).
So when Farage stood up in April 2025 and talked about over-diagnosis creating “a class of victims”, he was speaking a language with a long pedigree. You don’t need to have read a CCHR leaflet to repeat its logic. You just need to spend time around people who have.
How the idea travelled
Here’s the uncomfortable bit: Labour got there first. Farage was the crude version, not the source. The frame moved through ministers and reviews, and each step made it more respectable.
March 2025. Health secretary Wes Streeting says mental illness is “a spectrum and I think definitely there’s an overdiagnosis” (Benefits and Work).
24 April 2025. Farage says doctors are “massively over-diagnosing” and builds a “class of victims” on it. Mind, Rethink and the National Autistic Society condemn it (Rethink).
4 December 2025. Streeting commissions an independent review under Professor Peter Fonagy. He rows back, calling his own comments divisive (Channel 4 News).
31 March 2026. Fonagy’s interim report. Headlines run with young people being “incentivised” to get diagnosed (New Statesman).
28 May 2026. Milburn’s interim report: £25 on benefits for every £1 on getting young people into work.
9 October 2026. Fonagy’s final report: “we cannot conclude that overdiagnosis is occurring at scale” (GOV.UK).
17 November 2026. Milburn’s final report. The word “overdiagnosis” is gone. In its place: the “diagnose-wait-treat model”, which “plunges too many young people into the benefits system”.
That’s the fringe lineage, and it still matters. It just isn’t how the idea reached Whitehall. Whitehall had its own route.
What the data actually says
The over-diagnosis argument works by blending three different claims into one: distress is rising, diagnoses are rising, and benefit claims are rising. Pull them apart and the story changes.
1. The rise in distress is real
This is the government’s own review talking, not a charity press release. Among adults aged 16 to 64, common mental disorder rose from 15.5% in 1993 to 22.6% in 2024. Among 16 to 24 year olds it went from about one in six to about one in four. Fonagy says the rise “cannot be explained by greater awareness alone” (Fonagy executive summary).
NHS England’s own survey says the same. In 2023, 20.3% of 8 to 16 year olds had a probable mental disorder, as did 23.3% of 17 to 19 year olds and 21.7% of 20 to 25 year olds (NHS England). Eating disorders among 17 to 19 year olds went from 0.8% in 2017 to 12.5% in 2023 (NHS England).
A survey of symptoms is not a label handed out by a GP. You can’t over-diagnose your way to those numbers.
2. ADHD: the diagnoses have caught up, not overshot
Recorded ADHD among 12 to 17 year olds rose from 0.26% in 2000 to 3.88% in 2025. That sounds explosive. But Fonagy’s best estimate of true prevalence today is about 3.8%. That’s broadly stable, or only modestly up (Fonagy executive summary).
So for teenagers, recorded diagnosis has just about reached the level the condition was always at. That isn’t over-diagnosis. It’s a system finally counting what was already there.
Across all ages the gap is still huge. NHS England estimates almost 2.5 million people in England may have ADHD, against 549,000 likely waiting for assessment in March 2025 (Express & Star / NHS England).
3. Autism: the over-diagnosis camp’s best card, and its weak spot
Recorded autism among 6 to 11 year olds rose from 0.24% to 4.58%. The review’s best prevalence estimate is still about 1.2%. On the face of it, that’s the over-diagnosis case made.
But look at where the 1.2% comes from. The review itself says population prevalence data for autism and ADHD is “limited and less up to date than for many other conditions”. The US CDC, counting from health and school records, puts autism at about 1 in 31 eight year olds, or 3.2% (CDC via ABC). If you measure today’s diagnoses against an out-of-date denominator, you get a ratio that looks alarming whatever is actually going on.
One more thing the slogan misses: people now coming forward “are no less affected than those identified before” (Fonagy). If assessments were waving through the mildly quirky, you’d expect average severity to fall. It hasn’t.
4. The real queue
Open ADHD referrals passed 560,000 by the end of 2025, more than 17 times the 2019 figure.
Over 254,000 people had an open autism referral by December 2025.
The median wait for an autism assessment for 0 to 17 year olds is almost 600 days (Milburn, para 529).
Among people waiting over six months, “more than 7 in 10” say their difficulties are getting worse.
Sources: Fonagy executive summary; Milburn review.
This isn’t a country handing out labels like sweets. It’s a country making people wait two years for a label, then blaming the label.
What Fonagy found, and what Milburn borrowed
To be fair to Milburn, he doesn’t misquote Fonagy. He even notes that Fonagy “largely rejects the term ‘overdiagnosis’ because it implies that problems are not real” (para 513). Then he takes one half of Fonagy and quietly drops the other.
The half Milburn kept:
Diagnosis “has become the primary gateway to support”.
Neurodevelopmental prevalence is “largely flat” while diagnosis climbs.
The balance of risk “is changing” if current trends continue.
A strong line on participation: Milburn quotes Fonagy that “participation is not only an outcome of good health; it is one of the ways good health and wellbeing is built and sustained” (para 636).
The half Milburn left on the table:
A systematic review of 136 studies: when income goes up, mental health improves. When it goes down, mental health gets worse. The biggest effect comes from lifting people out of poverty.
The Universal Credit rollout in England was associated with a 6.6 percentage point rise in psychological distress among the people affected.
“Financial protection should sit alongside treatment and employment support”, so that the system doesn’t put up barriers to people re-engaging later.
Low participation “should not be read as lack of ability, motivation or aspiration”. Insecure or unsupported work can make mental health worse.
Source for both lists: Fonagy executive summary and Benefits and Work’s reading of the full report, pages 344 and 372.
Fonagy’s answer to “diagnosis is the gateway” is to open the gate earlier: give people help before, during and after assessment. Milburn’s answer is to take away what’s behind the gate.
Both say “needs, not labels”. Only one of them funds the needs before it removes what the labels unlock.
Follow the money
Strip out the warm language about guarantees and participation plans, and the fiscal engine of this review is youth health and disability benefits.
The bill Milburn wants to bend:
Spending on youth health and disability benefits rose from £1.7bn in 2019/20 to £4.7bn in 2025/26. On current policy it’s forecast to reach £8.8bn in 2036/37 (para 789).
The number of 16 to 24 year olds on DLA or PIP has doubled to over 400,000. On current trends 820,000 young people will be on PIP within ten years (para 633).
Anxiety, depression, ADHD and autism now account for almost two in three new claims in this age group (para 634). Their combined share as the primary condition for 16 to 24 year old PIP claimants rose from 49% in January 2020 to 64% in January 2026 (Benefits and Work).
What the review does about it, for under-25s:
The Work Capability Assessment and the UC health top-up “should be abolished”. “No new work-capability test should take their place” (para 745).
A single Youth Allowance replaces them, set at the standard under-25 UC rate, with more for those living independently (para 748).
PIP goes. In its place comes an Additional Cost Allowance for young people “whose disability-related extra costs are significant, well established and ongoing” (para 754).
What it saves: welfare savings start in 2029/30 and reach a cumulative £13.7bn by 2036/37 (para 742), running at £3.6bn a year by then (para 789). The review publishes those totals. As far as I can find, it doesn’t break them down measure by measure. So we can’t see how much comes from young people getting jobs and how much comes from young people getting less.
The catch-22 written into the allowance. “Well established” sounds reasonable until you put it next to the waiting list. The median wait for an autism assessment for under-18s is almost 600 days. More than 7 in 10 people stuck waiting over six months say they’re getting worse.
A young autistic person who turned 16 on that list will be close to 18 before anything about them is “established”. The same system that can’t assess them gets to decide that their costs aren’t proven yet.
And look at who’s in scope. It’s the conditions Farage singled out in 2025 that now make up the majority of new PIP claims among young people (para 735). The policy doesn’t need to call those diagnoses suspect. It just builds the suspicion into the test for getting paid.
The suit
Farage’s version was easy to swat. It said the diagnoses were fake and the victims were invented. Every charity in the country could rebut it before lunch.
Milburn’s version is cleverer. It admits the distress is real. It quotes Fonagy rejecting the word. It wraps everything in guarantees, named advisers and a paid job after twelve months. Some of that is genuinely good, and it deserves to be built.
Then it designs the money around the same suspicion Farage voiced out loud. You don’t need to say “over-diagnosis” if you abolish what the diagnosis unlocked.
That’s what I mean by a suit. The idea hasn’t changed. It has a better tailor.
There’s a simple test of whether Milburn means “needs, not labels”. Put the needs-led support in first, in every area, with assessment waits a young person can actually live with. Cut the cash afterwards, if the evidence says you should. The review has it the other way round: savings from 2029/30, Youth Opportunity Services everywhere “by 2029”, and a cut to what the label unlocks for anyone still waiting.
The government’s own clinician looked hard for over-diagnosis and couldn’t find it at scale. If ministers want to keep the policy anyway, they should at least have the decency to stop borrowing his name for it.
Sources
From a Welfare State to a Working State (Milburn review), DWP, 17 Nov 2026
Fonagy deals severe blow to Timms and Milburn, Benefits and Work
Milburn report slams failure to link PIP to work, Benefits and Work
Are too many people being diagnosed with ADHD and autism?, ITV News, Oct 2026
One in five children and young people had a probable mental disorder in 2023, NHS England
Almost 2.5m people in England likely to have ADHD, Express & Star / PA
Estimated 1 in 31 children have autism, ABC News on the CDC report
Farage accused of being out of touch after overdiagnosis comments, Nation.Cymru / PA, 24 Apr 2025
Nigel Farage says mental health conditions are over-diagnosed – we disagree, Rethink Mental Illness
Expert reacts to mental health services review, Channel 4 News, 4 Dec 2025
They call it over-diagnosis, Nigel, The Angry Dogs, Jul 2025




